Everyone remembers that memorable quote uttered by Dirty Harry about feeling lucky, but what exactly 'is' luck to us as heathens? The recent discussion on the NorthEastHeathen Yahoo group shed some light on the concept of luck; what it is, what it isn't and some good discussion followed and many questions were raised.
One of things I have noticed, albeit recently, is that a lot of heathens tend to lump the concept of luck into some sort of all encompassing 'thing' instead of looking at it for what it is. In the discussion we had it was brought up that one can have luck in some areas whilst not in others. One of the things we do on the NEH list is that I upload a specific paper to read and then we have a discussion on it. For this discussion Wilhelm Gronbech's Culture of the Teutons was given out as well as 'The Norse Concept of Luck' by Bettina Sejbjerg Sommer for a counter argument. I did this because of the differing conceptions of luck between these two authors. Gronbech seems to focus most of his attention in chapters 4 & 5 on the idea of individuals of luck or of luckless individuals whereas Sommers does not take the "all luck or no luck approach".
The concept of luck is a difficult one as there does not seem to be a singular 'type' of luck found anywhere in the lore.While some of those concepts may be related, they will have different meanings. If a man is known to be a 'man of luck' that luck would be different than say the luck found in ritual which in turn is also different from the lot of each man.
Gronbech feels that while you may have luck in different areas such as "luck of fertility" or "luck of cattle"or "would always have the wind in his favour", either you have luck or you don't, and if you don't or if it is negatively affected you are a nidhing. One of the questions that arose is how the words of someone standing in blot or sumbel would or could affect the luck of those present. One would then have to ask what luck is being affected by those actions and how if at all does this person's toast affect your luck. In order to determine if your luck is affected or not these questions have to be answered. Some answers could come from someone taking the approach of Bauschatz: 'your luck is affected because it has all been laid in the well of wyrd.', or how by Gronbech "if your luck is affected you are a nidhing", or Lonnroth " ill-luck is a disease that will spread to everyone that is associated with that individual". It could even come from one of our own, "I am not sure how his words in a largely uninvolved group will affect anyone in particular"....thanks Shane.
So you can see that luck isn't just one all encompassing thing but a many tiered concept that changes. Sommers believes that while in the source material we have examples of men who would be considered 'luckless' and in fact are nidhing yet in another we have instances of men who are luckless but their character seems to not suffer because they just happen to be dealing with bad circumstances. A man of renown and deed should not have bad luck but sometimes that is not the case just as a man who is luckless is not necessarily dishonorable. If you read Gronbech you will see according to him either that you are a man of luck or you are a nidhing and there is very little 'grey area.' A man who is luckless is a nidhing even though the source material may contradict that which Sommers points out.
As I have stated it is Gronbech's belief that a luckless man is a nidhing, a luckless man does not meet the ideal of a 'gifted man' but often he may meet other ideals such as that of the man who makes his way by the sweat of his brow and strength is his arms which will relate more to reputation in that a man earns his worth by the things he does.
This may be only a short summary of the discussion that follow regarding this topic but it is a concept that I strongly feel we as heathens should reevaluate based on not only the source material but academic material as well. I would like to thank all those on the NEH list for contributing to this discussion, particularly to Shane Ricks and Dan Orapollo whose responses I have used in the making of this entry.
This is an excellent post Gary, this blog is definitely a good idea :).
ReplyDelete